Let's take a step back in time and visit with the pilgrims this Thanksgiving. Rustic pilgrim pumpkin pie is an authentic pie baked in a pumpkin. It's as delightful to serve as it is to eat. It's a rustic pilgrim pumpkin treat.
You're going to love the flavor AND presentation of this charming rustic pumpkin pie.
**Please Note - The printable recipe card with detailed instructions, nutritional information, and complete ingredient measurements for making Rustic Pilgrim Pie is available near the end of this post. OR click on the "jump to recipe" button (found above) to be taken directly to the recipe.
If you've never roasted a real pumpkin in order to make a pumpkin pie, then you're missing out on part of the fun.
And, If you've never served your pumpkin pie in an actual pumpkin (as the pilgrims did), let's change all that!
The ingredient list:
**Note - The following lists of ingredients plus kitchen tools and equipment contain affiliate links (highlighted in blue) for your consideration and shopping convenience. #CommissionsEarned
- 3 pie pumpkins (approximately 6" in circumference), or 3 - ramekins
- brown sugar
- pumpkin purée
- eggs
- flour
- evaporated milk
- granulated sugar
- vanilla extract
- ground cinnamon
- ground nutmeg
- ground cloves
- pumpkin pie spice
- 1 round pie crust (optional for garnish)
- egg
- salt
Kitchen tools and equipment needed:
- Large mixing bowl
- Small Bowls
- Pumpkin Carving Tools
- Baking Sheet
- Parchment Paper
- Whisk
- Measuring Cups and Spoons
- Chef's Knife
- Cutting Board
- Nutmeg Grater
- Leaf Cookie Cutter (optional)
Food Service Equipment & Supplies
What's the difference between a pilgrim pumpkin pie and a regular pumpkin pie?
The taste is just as delicious as a traditional pumpkin pie baked in a crust, but a pilgrim pumpkin pie is charming to serve and doesn't require fiddling around with a lot of pie dough.
What is the best way to serve Pilgrim Pumpkin Pies?
Make sure to scoop and eat the actual pumpkin flesh from the vessel as you're eating the pie.
Since the entire pumpkin is baked in the oven along with the filling, the pumpkin will be soft and tender so don't miss out on all that extra flavor!
Depending on your appetite, the serving size of a rustic pumpkin pie may be quite large for one person.
I recommend cutting the entire pilgrim pumpkin pie in half and serving a half per person along with some whipped cream or vanilla ice cream (not shown).
What should I do with all the pumpkin seeds?
Excellent question!
Follow the links listed below and you'll be taken to all sorts of pumpkin seed recipes I know you're going to love!
- Bourbon Brown Sugar Pumpkin Seeds from Sweet ReciPEAS
- Coconut Maple Roasted Pumpkin Seeds from Lauren Kelly Nutrition
- 3 Tasty Pumpkin Seed Recipes from Kitchen Confidante
- Spiced Honey Roasted Pumpkin Seeds from The Chunky Chef
- Bourbon Bacon Pumpkin Seeds from Foodtastic Mom
Additional Thanksgiving dishes to grace your table:
- Turkey Bread Bowl with Spinach Dip Appetizer (pictured below)
"Amaze your family and friends with this Thanksgiving Turkey Bread Bowl Appetizer with Creamy Spinach Ranch Dip. He’s super easy to recreate, and Mr.Tom Turkey’s tail feathers play double duty as the dippers. What could be more fun?"
- Cinnamon Sweet Potatoes with Squash and Apples
- Pineapple Cardamom Cranberry Sauce
- Colorful Sautéed Autumn Vegetables with Bacon
- Pretzel Roll Stuffing with Pine Nuts (pictured below)
"Don't fool yourself into thinking this amazing pretzel roll stuffing with pine nuts should only be made for Thanksgiving. After your first bite, you'll be looking for reasons to make it all year long!"
- Balsamic Basted Herb Roasted Turkey
- Savory Pumpkin Sage Biscuits
- Fall Fruit and Vegetable Chopped Salad (pictured below)
"This fall chopped salad has all the colors and flavors you love about autumn! It will easily grace any table, for any occasion."
- Rustic Pilgrim Pumpkin Pie (pictured below) THIS IS THE PLACE!!
Below is the printable recipe card along with the exact ingredient measurements and nutritional information for making today's easy rustic pumpkin pie baked in a pumpkin.
⭐If you've made this recipe, or are excited to make this recipe, I'd appreciate it if you'd take a moment to leave it a star rating on the recipe card, along with a comment if you're so inclined. Thank you. 🙂
Pilgrim Pumpkin Pie
Ingredients
- 3 -6 " round pie pumpkins seeded and cleaned
To make the filling:
- 1½ cups roasted pumpkin pulp
- 1 can 15 ounces pumpkin purée
- 1 cup brown sugar
- 1 tablespoon all-purpose flour
- ½ teaspoon salt
- 1 teaspoon ground cinnamon
- 1 teaspoon pumpkin pie spice
- ⅛ teaspoon ground cloves
- ⅛ teaspoon grated nutmeg
- 1 teaspoon pure vanilla extract
- 4 large eggs
- 1¼ cup evaporated milk
For the garnish:
- 1 9 " round pie crust
- 1 egg
- 1 tablespoon water
- 2 teaspoons granulated sugar
- 1 teaspoon ground cinnamon
Instructions
To make homemade roasted pumpkin purée:
- Clean, seed, and quarter one pie pumpkin. Place on a baking sheet and roast at 425 for 30 minutes. Cool slightly, remove the flesh from the skin (discard the skin), and mash the flesh.
To prepare the pumpkin bowls for the filling:
- Clean and seed the remaining 2 pie pumpkins. Sprinkle the inside of the pumpkins with cinnamon and sugar. Set aside.
To make the filling:
- Preheat oven to 425-degrees.
- In a large bowl, whisk together the mashed pumpkin, pumpkin purée, brown sugar, flour, salt, cinnamon, pie spice, nutmeg, cloves, 3 eggs, vanilla, and evaporated milk.
- Place two of the cleaned pie pumpkins on a baking sheet and fill each with pumpkin pie filling. *Note - if you have any leftover, pour the remaining into a small baking dish or ramekin.
- Carefully place into the oven and partially bake for 30 minutes.
- While the pumpkin pies are baking, cut leaf shapes from the pie crust to garnish (optional).
- If garnishing, remove the pies from the oven and gently place the pie crust leaves on top of each pie.
- In a small bowl, whisk the final egg along with 1 tablespoon of water. Gently brush the egg wash on each pie crust leaf.
- Sprinkle the top with additional sugar and cinnamon and return to the oven for 50 minutes (or until the filling looks set and the pumpkin is soft when pierced with a toothpick.
- Cool the pies completely before serving and serve at room temperature, or chilled.
- To serve, cut each pumpkin into 4 wedges.
- Great with ice cream or whipped cream! Enjoy!!
Video
Nutrition
I sincerely hope you've enjoyed today's super easy and delicious pumpkin dessert as much as I've enjoyed bringing it to you!
This post may contain affiliate links which won’t change your price but will share some commission.
Lazy K says
6" in CIRCUMFERENCE? My 'Jack Be Little' Mini Pumpkin are 10" in circumference.
Renée says
The pumpkins I used were considered pie pumpkins and are smaller than pumpkins used for decorating.
I found mine in the produce section of the grocery store.
There are SO many sizes and varieties of pumpkins these days.
The larger pumpkin may work, but you'd most likely have to make one large dessert, and the baking time will be much longer.
I hope this is helpful, Lazy K.
Renee
Shar says
Looks like a fun recipe to try! Pilgrims didn’t have flour or ovens that first year though. The folks at the Plymouth museum believe that pumpkins were likely eaten like squash. Perhaps they used this recipe once four and ovens arrived on the scene. Can’t wait to try it.
Renée says
Thanks for the information. I suppose I took some liberties on the title, but the recipe itself is delicious.
Enjoy, Shar!
Sarah says
I love how you made the pie IN the pumpkin. Very rustic, very meta.
Renée says
Thank you, Sarah!
Wish I could say I came up with the idea, but the pilgrims did 😉
Renee
Jenn says
Loving the festive pie crust garnish for this tasty pumpkin pie recipe! Thanks for all your creative ideas and recipes!
Renée says
You're welcome, Jenn. It's my pleasure 🙂
Toni | Boulder Locavore says
What a gorgeous idea! I need to give this a try!
Renée says
Thank you. I hope you will.
Marjory says
Making the pie IN the gourd is genious! Love this recipe!
Renée says
Thank you, Marjory!
Amanda Finks says
I just love these pumpkin pies! Using the whole pumpkin makes this such a special dessert recipe!
Renée says
Thank you. I think so too!
Justine Howell says
Such a fun new idea to incorporate into our holiday baking with my kids, thanks!
Renée says
You're welcome. Glad you like this recipe!
Beth says
These are so clever. I cooked a savory dish in a pumpkin once but never my pies! I love this!
Renée says
Thank you. I've also made savory dishes in pumpkins but baking these pies were a first for me, too. They were delicious and so much fun to make!
Wilhelmina Wessel says
This is such a cool idea!!!
Renée says
Thank you, Wilhelmina!